Thank the heavens for cinema in 2018. I can say that about film pretty much every year, but in 2018—with the joint help of MoviePass (RIP) and AMC Stubs A-List (long live)—I saw more films than ever before, and escaped from the increasingly tumultuous world around me. Alongside my movie partner (and love of my life) Brianna, we saw upwards of 80 films in theaters in 2018, and have seen more than 70 films released in the calendar year of 2018, as of this writing. That’s a lot of movie-watching. There were some absolute stinkers (Tag is one of the most offensively horrible films I’ve ever seen; “teen” horror flicks like Blumhouse’s Truth or Dare, The Possession of Hannah Grace, and My Teacher, My Obsessionare so awful that I want to forget them from my memory; Vice was perhaps the most pandering, self-important dribble I’ve ever seen), plenty of middle-of-the-road films that are provided a much-needed decent time at the cinema (The Commuter, Bumblebee, Strangers: Prey at Night, and The Girl in the Spider’s Web), and movies and/or performances that have proven to be critically underrated (The Clovehitch Killer, Game Night, Bad Times at the El Royale, and the best performance of the year in Natalie Portman’s stunning turn as adult Celeste in Vox Lux). But the ten that we’ve ended up with at the top are something special, containing something or many things that shocked us, made us laugh, made us cry, and, most importantly, wowed us once again at the power of cinema. Thank whomever you want to, but thank someone that there continued to be important and jaw-dropping times at the cinema in 2018. – Brent & Brianna
Brent’s Top Ten
First, some honorable mentions: Unsane, Ocean’s 8, Avengers: Infinity War, Searching, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse.
- Roma
Roma is the most beautiful, heart-wrenching film of the year, and (if anyone in the Academy cared about my opinion) it would very likely get my vote for Best Picture. What makes Roma work so well is how relatable the whole film feels, even for a 23 year old white dude in Louisville, Kentucky. Alfonso Cuarón has such a deft touch behind the camera, and by never truly allowing Cleo (played with heartbreaking authenticity by Yalitza Aparicio) to leave the frame, his audience can’t help but feel every emotion that she feels, and experience every heartbreak right along with her. There’s a scene in Roma (captured in one of Cuarón’s signature single-takes) that’s the saddest of the year, and I would not do any justice spoiling it here. It can’t be longer than five minutes, but it feels like a painful eternity for the audience, and for Cleo. Roma is peak filmmaking, and the best part is that you can watch it from the comfort of your own home.
- Halloween (2018)
David Gordon Green’s Halloween should not be as good—or as scary, or simply as thrilling—as it is, but, nonetheless, here we are. Halloween (2018) is the best slasher film in recent memory, and succeeds in spite of the odds stacked against it. Jamie Lee Curtis (thankfully revived from her non-canonical demise in Halloween: Resurrection) is the only one who should ever play the role of Laurie Strode (much apologies to Scout-Taylor Compton), and this performance proves it—she’s terrific. John Carpenter (and company’s) score is scary as hell, and Halloween(2018) makes it clear that it was his thumbprint that was sorely missing from Rob Zombie’s reboots in the late 2000s. I’ll likely end up watching Halloween (2018) more than any other film from the year, and it’s immediately become a yearly viewing.
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
Sixteen years after his death, Fred Rogers is having a moment. With a Tom Hanks-starring biopic on its way later this year, and Morgan Neville’s touching, inspiring, and heartwarming documentary Won’t You Be My Neighbor?, it’s clear that Rogers’ status as one of America’s greatest treasures has been cemented. Rogers’ story is one worth telling: A tender, sweet man doing his best to make kindness and sincerity two traits that are available to us all, and presented to us while sitting on our couch. Won’t You Be My Neighbor? tells the story of a man simply too good and pure for this world, never drifting into sentimentality but remaining poignant and touching throughout. I left Won’t You Be My Neighbor? in a better mood than I did leaving any other film in 2018.
- Eighth Grade
It’s unfair to compare Elsie Fisher to Brooklynn Prince—the star of my favorite film last year, The Florida Project—because the films, though both run through the gamut of emotions, are so different. Still, Fisher’s performance in Eighth Grade is similarly as eye-opening as Prince’s, both performances displaying a stunning array of talent that we’re incredibly lucky to have seen, especially two years in a row. Fisher wears every bit of emotion right on her sleeve, perfectly capturing the nuances of Bo Burnham’s wonderful screenplay every second that she’s on screen. The scene towards the end of the film with Fisher’s Kayla and her father—the equally terrific and underrated Josh Hamilton—is pure and beautiful filmmaking, and beckons the audience to question what makes you, you. Gucci!
- Can You Ever Forgive Me?
This is the kind of film that Melissa McCarthy was meant to make. Can You Ever Forgive Me? allows her to fully become a new character, one that stands alone in her repertoire and gives her the chance to completely fall away into a role. Lee Israel is a complex character, but McCarthy absolutely nails it in a performance that’s equal parts hilarious, troubled, and inspiring. You can’t take your eyes off McCarthy as Israel, and the audience isn’t beckoned to either, as director Marielle Heller’s understated direction places Israel front and center, and rightfully so. You can’t ignore Best Supporting Actor favorite Richard E. Grant either, who nearly steals the show from McCarthy, and delivers a performance equally as complex and outstanding.
- BlacKkKlansman
Not only is BlacKkKlansman a terrific political commentary, it’s a pulse-pounding thriller, and a laugh-out-loud comedy to boot. A movie of this caliber and skill doesn’t come around too often, and as someone who claims Do The Right Thing as one of the best films to have never been nominated for Best Picture, it’s a personally-affecting triumph to see Spike Lee direct a film that rivals that one’s brilliance. Lee is the right director to tackle a story this unique and insane (and true!), and his decision to direct this story in 2018 is a wise one. His script—which he wrote with Charlie Wachtel, David Rabinowitz, Kevin Willmott—is tight and fiery, and the entire cast—particularly John David Washington, Adam Driver, and Topher Grace—rises to the occasion. Peak-Spike, indeed.
- Three Identical Strangers
Three Identical Strangers is the type of film that comes out of nowhere but leaves one of the biggest impacts. I had never heard of the titular strangers before walking into the theatre, but I left feeling like I had known them my whole life, thanks to the dynamic, holistic storytelling by director Tim Wardle. Three Identical Strangers is a complex movie, juggling twin concepts of nature v. nurture, fact and fiction, right and wrong. The highs and lows of the lives of its protagonists are honored and demonstrated here in a way that only a skillfully made documentary can, replicating a truly life-like experience. Three Identical Strangers remains the most surprising film I saw in 2018.
- Tully
Charlize Theron’s performance anchors Tully, as does Diablo Cody’s script, which is arguably her best yet, in addition to being one of the best of the year. Tully tells a story of motherhood that is so worthy of being told (yet so untold in a wide-release film) that its mere existence feels like a breath of fresh air. Thankfully, the film doesn’t merely exist; Tullylives and breathes, feeling as authentic as a documentary with the usual sardonic humor and depth that comes from a Diablo Cody-Jason Reitman pairing. It seems as though Charlize Theron will have to settle for a Best Actress – Musical or Comedy nomination at the Golden Globes which is a real shame because she’s never been better, and her chemistry with Mackenzie Davis in the titular role is beautiful and real, and heartbreaking.
- American Animals
American Animals is a film about failed American exceptionalism, a film that blatantly tells its audience they are not special and provides four examples of futile attempts to be special—the fact that I watched this film not long after Won’t You Be My Neighbor?, which preaches the opposite mantra, did not escape me. Despite this cynicism, I’ve seen American Animals more times than any other 2018 film, and I love every second of it. Perhaps it’s because of this cynicism that I’m so fascinated by the story it tells: that of a failed library heist, and the four individuals who become someone despite their insistence that they aren’t anyone. Bart Layton’s terrific script and unique docu-cinematic blend of storytelling—the real individuals involved in the heist taking up nearly as much screen time as the four talented young actors who portray them—and hip, fascinating editing by Nick Fenton, Chris Gill, and Julian Hart is going painfully unnoticed, which is a shame; Its tense, scary, and thrilling heist scene is worth the price of admission alone. The real gem of the film: A career-best, livewire performance from Evan Peters.
- Widows
What can I say; I’m a sucker for heist films. Widows, though, is special. Nearly everything about this film is pitch-perfect: Steve McQueen’s typically brilliant direction, getting the most out of each and every shot, along with his cinematographer Sean Bobbitt; a tight, fundamentally sound and structured script by McQueen and co-writer Gillian Flynn (who continues to prove that she’s the queen of everything); and absolutely terrific performances from the entire cast, especially Elizabeth Debicki, Brian Tyree Henry, BAFTA-nominated Viola Davis, and the terrifying, calculating, and outstanding Daniel Kaluuya (not even mentioning the superstar canine actor, Olivia). Widows, like American Animals before it, is a heist film that manages to do so much more, making a commentary on race relations in America in addition to poking holes in the shady world of local politics, and, in the end, promoting its own unique brand of feminine strength, a theme that’s thankfully becoming more common in film every year. Compound these traits with a heist plot that’s thrilling and jaw-dropping in all the right places and you’ve got Widows: the best film of 2018.
Brianna’s Top Ten
- Hereditary
Let’s face it, I’m a sucker for any dysfunctional family dramas. I’m not sure what it is about them that appeals to me; perhaps I see glimpses of my own family in there or maybe I just enjoy the chaos of knowing mine isn’t thatcrazy. But Hereditarytakes the dysfunctional family trope to new and horrifying heights with this film which features so many bone chilling and heart racing moments, I can’t remember the last time I was so unsettled and concerned about what the filmmakers would subject me to next. The final 15 minutes or so of this movie were better than most of the mainstream horror releases of the decade. Some of the elements of this film are clearly taken from some classics but Ari Aster wonderfully delivers some much-needed originality into the dying horror genre. You’ll never hear that tongue clicking noise the same again.
- Ocean’s 8
It’s not an exaggeration to say that when this film was announced as a female lead sequel to Ocean’s 11-13, that people (mostly insecure angry men and incels) were kind of upset. “What do you mean there’s no Clooney?” they cried. Many refused to give it a chance but if they would’ve saw past their narrow minded, misogynistic lens, they would’ve seen a sharp, stylish and quite funny film about eight women from different backgrounds both economically, culturally and racially coming together for one of the coolest and perhaps most improbable heists ever on screen. But if your biggest hang up about this film is that it’s not realistic, then really ask yourself how realistic Fast and the Furious, Harry Potteror Mission: Impossible movies are. Movies are sometimes just for fun and an escape, and Ocean’s 8provides that.
- Beautiful Boy
For better or for worse, 2018 was full of films about the perils and strife of drug addictions. Couple this film with Netflix’s 6 Balloons(also a great film) and Peter Hedges’ Ben is Backand you’ve got an unofficial, quite depressing, but realistic trilogy of addiction in today’s world – especially as it relates to heroin. Beautiful Boyin particular sees Timotheé Chalamet transform from a cute, average teenage boy into a young man deep in the bowels of his addiction and nearly dying more than once. It’s a biopic and so with a quick Google search you can easily read a quick summary of what happened to the real family but this movie is so poetically and carefully done that it’d be a real shame to miss out on seeing Chalamet and Steve Carell act their hearts out. This film isn’t an easy one to sit through but it’s important, timely and surprisingly, full of hope.
7. Game Night
This film was undoubtedly my first favorite film of 2018 and though it didn’t stay in the top spot, it was still the funniest movie of the year. Jesse Plemons’ character “Gary” is both parts creepy and hilarious. Every bit of dialogue, and the editing are masterful, and the film plays out like one big giant game. Rachel McAdams and the always charming Jason Bateman have amazing chemistry both with each other and the rest of the cast which makes the viewing experience all the more enjoyable. It’s rare, I feel, for me to want a sequel to a film so badly but that’s just how great this movie truly was. Who doesn’t enjoy the camaraderie of friends getting together for games of chance and skill?
6. BlacKkKlansman
It’s probably important to note that this was my introduction to Spike Lee’s filmography, which as a budding cinephile like myself is quite shameful, I know, but this film was exquisite. There were moments of genuine laughter (we all love David Bowie, by the way) and moments of disgust and horror. Topher Grace playing David Duke is a million times scarier than him playing Venom in Spider-Man 3. The story, which sounds wa, too convoluted to be real, plays out brilliantly and at the end for a brief moment you feel vindicated. But then Spike Lee delivers a brutal but necessary reminder of the evils that still live in this world and that racism is FAR from over… sorry “all lives matter” peeps.
- Halloween (2018)
Let’s be real. When I heard that David Gordon Green, the director of Pineapple Express(which yes, is a fantastic stoner comedy) andDanny McBride, also of Pineapple Expressfame, among other things, were going to be bringing up a new Halloweenmovie, I really began to believe we lived in a simulation. I could’ve never guessed that they would somehow be able to revitalize a franchise that had been soiled time and time again with countless subpar sequels (there’s really no excuse for Halloween 6or Resurrectionfor that matter), but they did with great brilliance. Halloween(2018 – NOT 1974 or 2007) was a welcomed edition for me, a wannabe horror aficionado and lover of Michael Myers. The story, the acting, the moments of sheer horror (the scene at the end of the movie when Laurie is walking around that house in the dark…my life still hasn’t known peace) all created this masterpiece of horror cinema. It gave old fans endless Easter eggs and it gave new fans a way into this crazy but fun franchise. I’ve never loved Jamie Lee Curtis more nor have I ever been more terrified for her.
4. Spider-Man: Into the Spiderverse
I’m a tad bit biased on this one because Spider-Man has been, is, and always will be my favorite superhero. I’ve seen every live action Spider-Man film from Tobey Maguire to Tom Holland, and I mostly loved them all in their own way (sorry, but Spider-Man 3… wyd?). Not only do we get a biracial Spider-Man in Miles Morales but we also get Spider Gwen, Spider-Man Noir (hell YES Nicolas Cage) and an Asian Spider-Woman all in one. This movie is sweet, action packed and hilarious – a perfect movie for all kids who find themselves under represented in other superhero movies. This movie gives you the feeling that you too, can be Spider-Man. And PS. I totally want a Spider Gwen t-shirt now.
3. Widows
How often do we see a film that shows women (three of which are of color!) in positions of power versus peril? Widowsshows young girls everywhere that you are capable of doing whatever the hell you want, frankly, and albeit most of us won’t go out and plan a heist, it sure does look stylish and exciting and powerful in this brilliant film. Viola Davis is, as always amazing, and Elizabeth Debicki is as mesmerizing as she is tall (note: she’s 6’3”!). What a goddamn shame this film has flown so far under the radar but Widowsis IT.
- Eighth Grade
How is it utterly possible that a fully grown man could so perfectly capture the torture of being an 8th grade girl teetering on the edge of just having been thrust into puberty and nearly being old enough to drive a car? Eighth grade (the actual grade not the film) is a time filled with so much awkwardness and discomfort, it’s hard to believe any of us survive it. But Bo Burnham created the perfect picture of what I imagine being a preteen is like in today’s Snapchat and Instagram world, and still managed to leave in the timeless struggles of not fitting in and feeling insecure. Elsie Fisher is irresistibly adorable as she is awkward and how utterly refreshing it is to finallysee a teen girl playing a teen girl (Riverdale, do better). There’s not a single scene or line or character that goes to waste and the scenes between Kayla (Fisher) and her father (Josh Hamilton) are some of the most heartwarming and real scenes ever put on film. A classic film that will live on for years and will serve as a reminder to all young girls that they’re not alone in feeling weird or uncool.
- Won’t You Be My Neighbor?
When you’re really little you often idolize celebrities, and when you grow up you realize most of the time they’re problematic in one way or another, because they’re human. That’s not the case for Mister Fred Rogers, a truly pure, wholesome and kind soul. Of course I’ve never met Mister Rogers, not really anyways unless you consider all the times I watched his show as a child and fell in love with his soft voice and routine of changing into a cardigan (is that where I get my love of a good cardigan? Maybe). But this documentary is a clear love letter to the memory of a man who affected so many children and adults alike. I was enthralled the entire time and (secretly and shamefully) kept waiting for a moment in which my view of this man would be shaken – surely someone had something bad to say about him or surely he did something problematic, but no. Instead I listened to his wife, children, friends and loved ones speak about how amazing of a man he was and I couldn’t help but feel sad that he was no longer alive in this world which has been plagued with tragedy and darkness. His presence in the world was a light, and this documentary was incredibly illuminating as well. I’ve always loved Mister Rogers but Won’t You Be My Neighbor?helped me realize how much of a hero he was and still is to me. Beautiful filmmaking.
Brent’s Bottom Five
- Blumhouse’s Truth or Dare
I think it’s worth noting that this movie made a boat-load of money (almost $100 million dollars worldwide!). Horror films will continue to make a profit in the near future because they’re made for such little money, and because horror films strike a chord that resonates with an audience’s wallet unlike any other genre. The Jason Blum machine is very real, so why did he decide to put his company’s name in the official title of this utter dumpster fire? Given the youthful nature of the cast and their presence on popular teen television shows (Pretty Little Liars’ Lucy Hale and Teen Wolf’s Tyler Posey, neither of whom know how to act convincingly like adults), it’s clear who this film is marketed towards, but that doesn’t excuse lazy and unfocused direction, a genuinely awful script, and an alienating, utterly confounding twist ending. You’d think that one of the film’s four credited screenwriters would know how young people speak, but that isn’t the case as Truth or Dare features some of the worst dialogue of 2018. Maybe a party game just isn’t the best basis for a feature film (see the 2017 Syfy original movie of the same name for further proof).
- My Teacher, My Obsession
- The Possession of Hannah Grace
- Christmas with a View
- Tag
Brianna captured my feelings for our shared bottom four quite well, so I’m going to let her speak for me.
Brianna’s Bottom Five
- Dude
Somehow two of my least favorite 2018 films have Lucy Hale in them. I’m not surprised seeing as how the only film to date I can remember enjoying of hers is Scream 4… which isn’t saying much. Admittedly, I was excited to see a female led stoner comedy as so little of those exist (I love you so much, Smiley Face) but this was… not it. Four girls, two of which are really just background characters (Awkwafina, girl, why are you playing a high school senior??) smoke weed and drink and have sex, just teen stuff. There’s some weird sexual relationship between one girl and her teacher and some unspoken and not really addressed r*pe scene as well. All in all, this movie is disappointing and forgettable.
- My Teacher, My Obsession
Yikes. A teacher who looks more like a former male model or adult film actor becomes the crush of a teenage girl because we lovethe crazy, boy obsessed, psychotic girl tropes, don’t we?? The teacher, of course, nearly has sex with his student – who thankfully, I guess, is 18 – although if we’re being honest, the fact that he’d almost have sex with her is gross and weird because A) he’s her goddamn teacher and that’s a major imbalance of power and B) she’s barely 18! The rest of the film plays out like any generic lifetime movie you’ve seen before and is essentially soft core porn. A David Fincher directed film, this movie is not.
- The Possession of Hannah Grace
If you watched the trailer, you watched the movie. There are absolutely no moments of suspense if you’ve ever seen an American paranormal horror flick before, and the titular Hannah Grace is more alive than this film’s energy (and she’s dead). Also, if you were expecting a movie about a girl named Hannah Grace becoming possessed, then get over it because the movie begins afterthe possession has taken place, because fuck you, I guess. Instead we get to follow Megan, played by Shay Mitchell, who’s an ex-cop and addict trying to rid herself of her guilt over her partner being shot and killed; her drug/alcohol addiction however is merely a plot device used to make her seem crazy and unstable when things at her morgue start getting weird. Sadly, the filmmakers drastically overestimated how much I cared about Megan judging from that lackluster end scene.
- Christmas with a View
I literally remember almost nothing about this film and sure, it could be because I was so bored I was on my phone or because I cringed so hard my face began to hurt at the dialogue. But this movie with its weird lighting (???) and it’s basic as fuck romance was not worth remembering anyways. If you’re looking for a Hallmark-brand Christmas movie, obviously you’re not looking for high quality filmmaking but this movie is so formulaic and dull. But if you’re a city planner then maybe you’ll enjoy a very odd scene in which a female character proclaims that unlike mostcity planners, her man is notboring. Thank God.
- Tag
Imagine the worst group of adult friends ever to grace a movie screen – literally – and their main objective the entire film is to tagtheir friend, played by Jeremy Renner. It feels unfair to compare this disaster of a movie to the film Game Nightbut in a very basic way they have a similar premise (friends getting together to play a game of some sort but things going awry). But unlike Game Night, Tagis chock full of weirdly unnecessary narration and slow motion action scenes, painfully unfunny dialogue mostly coming from Jake Johnson and oh yes, a miscarriage joke – because what is funnier than something that thousands of women go through all the time! Tagis undoubtedly and irredeemably, garbage.